Wednesday 9 January 2013

Bad Floral Foam!!


Happy New Year!! (Unfortunately there are no photos or funny pictures today as the blogger program does not want to load anything...bad blogger!!)

I would like to touch on the subject of New Year’s resolutions. I have been reading and thinking about the benefits of recycling, the environment and the general well being of fauna and flora. With the New Year I finally took action.

We enjoy the beautiful flowers nature gives us, but we do not always return the favour. I have come to realise that we, as florists, have a big responsibility to keep our carbon footprint as small as possible. Without the beautiful flowers nature provides we would be stuck in a tiny grey office on the 25th floor - any florist’s nightmare!

All the products florists use to make the arrangements our clients buy are disposable; it's not something you would keep for a long period of time. Once the flowers die you throw the baskets, plastic wrap, oasis, green florist bowls away. Most of these products end up at the rubbish heap and gets buried at the landfill site. Out of sight, out of mind is how the saying goes. Cape Town, alone, produces 6000tons of waste PER DAY! To put it into perspective, that is 1.7 to 2kg of waste per person per day (1). One ton of waste will fill a 3m x 2m room (to the ceiling) with waste (2).

Floral foam is the product I use to create floral arrangements for table centrepieces, etc. I have always wondered what it is made of and whether or not it is biodegradable. Sadly I learnt that it is not biodegradable. After testing it on rats and rabbits (which breaks my heart), they found it to be harmful to people when exposed to it over long periods of time...like me. (3)

The basic "emergency overview" is that is "may be irritating to eyes, skin, and respiratory tract" (3). Personally I have not experienced any of these symptoms.

It contains the following chemicals (which explains the abovementioned symptoms):

Formaldehyde - Formaldehyde is highly toxic to all animals, regardless of method of intake. Ingestion of as little as 30 ml of a solution containing 37% formaldehyde has been reported to cause death in an adult human. Water solution of formaldehyde is very corrosive and its ingestion can cause severe injury to the upper gastrointestinal tract. At concentrations above 0.1 ppm in air formaldehyde can irritate the eyes and mucous membranes, resulting in watery eyes. Formaldehyde inhaled at this concentration may cause headaches, a burning sensation in the throat, and difficulty breathing, and can trigger or aggravate asthma symptoms (4).

Barium Sulphates - Although soluble salts of barium are moderately toxic to humans, barium sulphate is nontoxic due to its insolubility. The most common means of inadvertent barium poisoning arises from the consumption of soluble barium salts mislabelled as BaSO4 (5).

Carbon Black - is a material produced by the incomplete combustion of heavy petroleum products such as FCC tar, coal tar, ethylene cracking tar, and a small amount from vegetable oil. (6)

Although these products are all ingredients in floral foam it should be taken into consideration that the extracted discussion above relates to the chemicals in general and is not related to their behaviour in the floral foam. These are not the only ingredients in floral foam and therefore the ones mentioned above is only a small component of the overall product.

Having one brick of floral foam in your house probably won't be harmful. Working in the factory that produces floral foam might be an entirely different situation.

At this stage I am looking for a biodegradable replacement, but I cannot find any in South Africa. I have, however contacted a company in the UK and enquired about the products they have available. They advised me that they are working on the development of the product and will keep me posted on their progress.

Well, there you have it. I think everyone agrees that this information should be printed on the box. Sadly it is not. My new year's resolutions are therefore to find alternative ways of arranging flowers and in the meantime to continue to advise my clients to please recycle the Oasis floral foam bricks, to keep it away from children and pests and to dispose of it as soon as the arrangement has wilted and died.

 

 

17 comments:

  1. Hello there

    I'm a florist based in Melbourne Australia and read your article with great interest. I have banned foam in my business and am always testing out alternatives, but still nothing beats good old life-giving water. I am suprised at just how few florists understand what this is made of and that it can be harmful.
    I'd be really interested in conversing with you directly, could you possibly email me at christie@floriography.com.au?

    There are many more like us on the lookout for an alternative and I'd love to keep in touch,

    Christie
    floriography.com.au

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice blog and very happy when I read your blog this very nice.This is true that flower is life of the peoples because without flower or greenery the life is not god because if we tired form the work and then if we sit for a few minutes in a garden s we feel very relax.
    best florist :-florist:-cheap florist in jaipur:-Best florist in jaipur

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Again,

    Just following up with an article I wrote about my concerns with the safety of floral foam
    http://floriography.com.au/index.php/2013/05/q-just-how-green-is-floral-foam/

    Please feel free to send me an email or write a comment with your feedback.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. have been thinking the same, and trying to think of alternative to use for pedesttal arrangements in church, can only think of chicken wire, so might give it a go next time, but can't think that it will work!

      Delete
  4. The first several months of my site there were no comments; just give it time; now they come in like crazy every day! Thanks.
    mattress for back pain

    ReplyDelete
  5. It sounds like a dream come true as an alternative to the toxic non-biodegradable floral foam we florists have used for years!

    I haven't tried it yet - but I sure do plan to!

    http://www.floralsoilsolutions.com/

    https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/floral-soil-forever-botanical-cupcakes#/story

    http://www.marthastewart.com/americanmade/nominee/138495/design/floral-soil-llc--floral-soil-botanical-cupcakes

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Floral Soils is fabulous. We are so happy to be using it and look forward to it being more available as the inventor scales for more production.

      Delete
  6. Sand, glass beads, paper towel, earth, wadded up wire, wood chips etc.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Hello,

    I know this post is a few years old but I was wondering if you kept in touch with the U.K. company you mentioned? If so, could you tell me their name?

    I have contacted Floral Soil Solutions to enquire about some samples of their product but I would also be interested in speaking to local companies in the UK.

    Stuart

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi, I have developed a non toxic, recyclable floral design solution. Budable. It's a flexible, reusable cap that fits any shape vase and can be used over and over. Check it out at www.budable.com

    ReplyDelete
  9. I've been a floral designer for over 45 years and every shop I was employed at used the Smithers Oasis floral foam. Years of pulling the dry foam blocks out of the boxes leaning over and yanking each block out while breathing in the tiny dust particles of the foam then thrusting my hands into tubs of water soaked bricks. In 2011 during Christmas I suddenly noticed severe itching and burning on my hands. The skin on my fingers began to peel, dry up and peel more. By the week before Valentines day I had lost the top layer of skin on both hands, wrists and halfway down my arms. I tried doctors, steroids, bandages, cotton gloves, salves, latex gloves but it got so bad I was no longer able to work. Everything I tried to do with my fingers and hands became horribly painful. During the week before Valentine's Day, two young girls were hired to help us in the shop and after 3 days they began to complain that their hands were itching and burning. When I questioned my manager about the foam he said he had just purchased the newest Oasis Foam that claimed to be more absorbent? We checked the box for any warning labels but found nothing. I called Smithers requesting an OSHA report on the foam which I did receive from the receptionist. What we saw on the report was shocking! The symptoms from formaldehyde exposure, the warning to wear something over your mouth because of the toxic dust from the blocks to the fact that when you put the brick into water the formaldehyde becomes a noxious gas and soaks through skin, gloves etc. So even wearing gloves is useless in keeping exposure at bay. After 6 months my doctor gave up. After a year my hands were finally healed. I didn't go back to floral work as the fear and pain too great of it happening again. I had phoned Smithers more than once questioning them for NOT including a warning on the boxes or an OSHA report inside each box regarding the formaldehyde they were using as a preservative in their floral foam. On one call I could tell they had me on speaker phone and there were people at their end listening in on the conversation and occasionally someone else would speak. In the end they accused me of being allergic to flowers and refused to acknowledge that I was experiencing a reaction to the formaldehyde. I had no money to pursue legal action using what little I had at the time to pay for medical expenses. Later I tried to get a second copy of the OSHA report but was denied.

    In 2016, a friend of mine who owns a little floral shop within a funeral home was looking for someone to step in for her at her shop while she was out of town and I accepted. It was just 2 1/2 days and her arrangements are always without oasis. However, while she was away we had a funeral and I ended up making a casket spray and two easel sprays. I even had the delivery driver place the blocks into the casket saddle but I had to touch the blocks in order to get them secure. Very little contact was made with the two easel sprays as I was extremely cautious just in case. But with this tiny amount of contact just 4 days later I felt the familiar tingling, itching and burning on both hands and once again here I am after all these years with skin loss on fingers, rashes under the skin of fingers, and palms, pain and anger! Again this product has created severe affects on my hands.

    What many designers may believe is happening to their skin is eczema is in reality the affects of formaldehyde exposure and poisoning. And this company refuses to put any kind of warnings, labeling, etc. on their products. Anyone who reads this please stop using this product! You have been exposed to a dangerous chemical that will eventually if not already caused you bodily harm.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Many interesting discussions about floral foam. In 2014 Smithers-Oasis created a new formulation for floral foam, called OASIS(R) Floral Foam MAXlife. This floral foam is 100% biodegradable in 567 days. More information about the floral foam can be found at https://oasisfloralproducts.com/ctemplate1.aspx?page=App_Themes/default/html/MaxLife_FAQs_en-US.html

    If you have further questions, please feel free to contact me by phone 330-676-4416 or email jsirlouis@smithersoasis.com

    Jacque Sir Louis
    Dir. of Marketing
    Smithers-Oasis
    919 Marvin Street
    Kent, Ohio 44240

    ReplyDelete
  11. I’m gald to see so many people are concerning the styrofoam recycling and reusing. Because my company is a specialist who can provide total solution to waste styrofoam recycling and reusing. If you are interested, please link the website to learn more: http://www.intcorecycling.com/styrofoam-recycling-solutions.html .

    ReplyDelete
  12. here is a biodegradable version...you probably found out about this by now.

    http://www.smithersoasis.com/2014/12/greening-the-floral-industry-with-oasis-floral-foam-maxlife/

    ReplyDelete